Tuesday, September 12, 2017

I can ‘do Jewish’ on just $40,000 a year

http://blogs.timesofisrael.com/i-can-do-jewish-for-40000/

Last year, I was a 45-year-old married father of four children, a member of a large American Modern Orthodox Jewish community, and I didn’t have a penny saved in the bank. I decided to get serious about my finances and sit down with a financial planner. He told me that in order for me to be able to pay for my four children to go to college, and to have any semblance of a retirement for myself and my wife, we would need to save 50 percent of our net income for the next 20 years. We began to itemize my family’s major expenses:



  • Day school tuition – approximately $80,000 post tax dollars a year. Currently consuming nearly 50% of our post tax annual take home pay.

  • Housing and utilities – near a synagogue, walking distance, big enough for 4 kids, another large sum of money.

  • Health insurance – my employer only plays 50 percent, leaving me with almost $900 a month to pay to cover the family

  • 2 cars

  • Jewish Summer camp – with 4 kids in various combinations of summer camps, both home and away, plus all associated flights and gear, approx $20,000.

  • Kosher food – At times coming to more than $1,000 a month

  • Additional outlays: to Jewish charities, synagogue dues + building fund, and more, as well as life insurance, tolls, and random other surprises.

  • Dollars left for savings, investment, college tuition, wealth building: Zero

  • We reviewed this short list of items and my advisor said, “You realize the greatest expense to your life is your religion. It is consuming over half of your post tax take home pay. You are paying almost $150,000 a year to ‘do Jewish.’”


And that’s when I realized I had forgotten to include Passover on the list.

I’m not alone
This was the wakeup call of the century for me. I was raised to believe that religion came first; that everything was ‘holy’ and a ‘mitzvah’; that the more you spent on your Judaism the better it was in God’s eyes. And I now realized I had been completely neglecting the financial health and future of my family.

The first thing I did was to ask around how other people were managing it. Word on the street was that to do everything on my list in a “second tier” community, not something in the greater New York area, one would have to earn more than $500,000 a year. Now I work very hard and I do pretty well, but I will most likely never make half a million dollars a year. Granted, some people in the community do, but not many.

What I saw was far more people who were – if they were willing to admit it – getting steady monthly checks from their parents to survive. Adult children 50 years old still living off handouts from their parents in order to “do Jewish.” Some parents had large fortunes and were easily able to afford to help several adult children, but some were slowly being bled dry. I had one grandmother tell me, “It’s wrong that the day schools are now trying to fund themselves off the backs of the grandparents, now that they have already broken the parents.”

Even more concerning, were the large number of families, doctors, lawyers, investment professionals, who, when asked in confidence, replied that they don’t have two pennies to rub together. And that was before their children were setting off to years in Israel and very expensive college in New York.

The day I left the synagogue forever was the Saturday the rabbi preached that day school tuition does not fulfill the obligation to give 10 percent of one’s income to charity — and that from a rabbi making $350,000 a year, along with free tuition, free housing, and free food expenses. As I angrily began to walk out of there for the last time, my neighbor grabbed my tallis and told me “The day the rabbis pay full tuition is the day that the tuition crisis will be solved.”

‘You’re in or you’re out’
Let’s spend a little more time on the tuition crisis in Modern Orthodox day schools, since this was the greatest expense for me. With four kids in school and an upper middle class income, I was told I had to pay full tuition for all four kids with no sibling discounts (and no reprieve from constant fundraising calls).

At one point, I went to the school president, a major donor (independently wealthy) to the school. I explained that keeping all my kids in the school would mean never saving a penny for retirement or college, and asked if there was any plan for helping working middle class parents, such as capping tuition at a percentage of income, or providing a sibling discount. His reply: “You’re in or you’re out.”

So I took myself out.

I enrolled my kids in an excellent private secular school for a third the cost of the “excellent” Jewish day school. And now, a year later, you know what I’ve found? That my kids are not running a year behind public school in their education; That kids actually have discipline and respect for their teachers; And even more importantly, that all children who misbehave are handled in the same manner, instead of letting the children of the wealthy supporters get away with murder. And even more interesting, this amazing secular school had all of…drumroll…one principal — the Day School I left had five. Enough said.

In hindsight, I remember when a Muslim I worked with asked me one day why I was so stressed out. I said because I have to make so much money to pay for my kids to go to school. He asked me how much tuition I was paying per kid and when I answered $20,000, he said, “Wow, you’re getting screwed. We in the Muslim school are paying only $5,000.” Of course their school also had only one principal.

I had now left day school and synagogue, and my life was only getting better. Not just financially, but emotionally as well. I actually didn’t have to work as hard, and started to have more time with my family. I knew fathers working five jobs to pay the Jewish bills, or taking jobs out of town, showing up for weekends at home, or even putting their families in Israel and flying back one week a month. This is no recipe for ‘Shalom Bayit.’

Kosher food came next. I set a $200 a month limit for my wife on spending in the local Kosher butcher shop. Some chicken breast, some wings. There is no health benefit to eating meat more than maybe twice a month. Now that I look at the prices, I am actually shocked the communities have not simply boycotted these establishments en masse.

Passover? Forget about it. We just do it at home now. I toss that one up there as a luxury on par with buying a country club membership or a small yacht.

Summer camp? Chabad. In fact, we have been getting more involved with Chabad. At least they don’t make Judaism all about the money. Sure, they also need community support to exist, but in return they provide full-service Judaism at a reasonable price. That in my opinion, will effectively position Chabad as the ‘last man standing’ of US Jewish Orthodoxy, as the far right Jewish communities become increasingly impoverished due to the failure to educate their kids for the workforce, and as the Modern Orthodox numbers continue to dwindle under lack of commitment, unbearable costs and attrition in the college years and beyond.

Time for a revolution
Over the past year, our family has rewritten our financial future. We now live on half of our income and invest and save the rest. And thanks to this new president, the financial markets have been doing great. We pulled our kids out of Jewish day school and they are getting a better education in a better environment, and we supplement their Jewish education via Chabad. I am now able to comfortably “do Jewish” for $40,000 a year, the sum my financial planner told me needed to be our limit. You know what, we may even be able to go away next year for Passover!

The overpriced balloon of the Modern Orthodox experience rests on three core flaws:

Jewish organizations are too top heavy, with too many positions filled by wives and cronies, and with amply-paid rabbis who are out of touch with the financial woes of their congregants.

There are too many very wealthy board members controlling too much of the decision-making for the wider Jewish community. It’s time to get some working class and even poor people on the boards of schools and JCCs.

Too many sheep just go right along, with their heads buried in the rear end of the sheep in front of them. It’s time for a revolution.

What kind of revolution?

How about launching a month-long community boycott of all neighborhood kosher markets? (Start two weeks before Passover.) Or pulling the kids out of day school, demanding charter schools, and insisting that the local rabbis earn their fat salaries by holding lowcost Jewish after-school programs in the synagogue.

As we gear up for the High Holidays – by the way, my Chabad doesn’t charge mandatory ticket fees – it’s time to take an honest look at where Modern Orthodox Judaism is going. For me it was a $150,000 a year post tax commitment, a sum of money that most people never even come close to earning.

Religious leaders have no right to complain about intermarriage rates in the US when the religion is being priced out of affordability. And don’t even get me started on the shidduch crisis, although if you look honestly at the problems of matchmaking and failure to find a mate, there too you find that much of the problem also comes back to who has the most money. It’s time to take back our religion, to make it more accessible to Jews of all financial situations.

Those who stand in the way of this progress should be expelled from the community. The legacy rabbinate and top-heavy institutions are not sustainable in the long term. They’ve bankrupted the parents. They are now trying to bankrupt the grandparents. That was never the way this religion was supposed to be.

11 comments :

  1. The author certainly raises some valid points, and very key ones in my opinion. However, the general wisdom seems to say that statistically, his kids become much more at risk of assimilation (which he seems not to really care much about ("Religious leaders have no right to complain about intermarriage rates in the US when the religion is being priced out of affordability"). It seems people further on the right are slightly better off (we don't have rabbis earning such salaries nor do any of the schools my kids are in have >1 principal). But average family in our community earns much less than the average Modern Orthodox family... Certainly something to address, but I would not do it the way he did...

    ReplyDelete
  2. I am relatively speaking, rich, ie, i can afford Jewish. That said, the writer loses some of my sypmathy when he talks about going away for passover, a real luxury. I am not in a mod ox community, so my per child tuition is well south of 20k per child.

    ReplyDelete
  3. He's right on the money about the rest of the savings, like doing Passover at home.
    But if you think he's going to have Jewish grandchildren by sending his children to a non orthodox school, you're mistaken.
    This is one man who sold his soul for money.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Intermarriage or poverty? Those are not the real choices. How about poverty and no marriage, since they won't be able to afford it? Since when has it become permitted to use the Torah as a spade with which to dig (and earn big money)?
    Torah is free, it does not need to be commercialised.
    $20-40,000 per year per child for school fees is outrageous. Not everyone can even earn that amount.
    The "halacha" or strict yeshiva interpretation of it, is destroying people and preventing them from living honest lives. One modern Rosh Yeshiva of mine said you need to learn 10 years in yeshiva to know anything.
    What if people stopped funding yeshivas and kashruth (same discussion on hechsherim).? If this guy's actions are replicated by enough people, the school and yeshiva system will collapse. That means the teachers are benefitting financially from his sorrow.

    ReplyDelete
  5. good for you. what about all those poor bastards can't afford it?

    ReplyDelete
  6. "Your kids will marry out" is a powerful scare tactic, but is it true?

    ReplyDelete
  7. Are you asking me for a guarantee?
    Scare tactic? There are millions of Jews in the United States today that intermarried or left their faith due to a lack of Jewish schooling.
    That number is much, much more than the amount that we lost due to the lack of proper College Prep.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Regular frum schools in NYC or Lakewood don't charge 20K per child, and they're giving a decent "Jewish" education. (I think that I got one).

    I suspect that major components of the 20K price tag, have very little to do with "Jewish". MOs seem to be fond of fancy school buildings, huge general education budgets, and huge the extracurricular activity budgets, all of which have little to do with "Jewish".

    So don't blame it on "Jewish". Blame it on "Modern".

    ReplyDelete
  9. you are making big assumptions here. People have a thing called free will. the whole emancipation and haskalah movement began in yeshivot - they had education but - for whatever reasons - chose to leave. The Besht's son had Jewish schooling but still became a maskil; R' Eybeschutz's son became a Sabbatean;

    Reform and Conservative also have day schools but they have the big assimilation. Reform is 200 years old, so secular Jews have been secular for even longer.

    Even in the very frum world, there is a growing OTD movement, so there are no guarantees. Rav Bernstein of London ztl once said "20 years ago i would have said there are guarantees, but now I am older and wiser". he was talking precisely about assimilation and preventing it.

    ReplyDelete
  10. It could be the modern Orthodox live in very expensive suburbs like Manhattan that is certainly the case in London but education is not as expensive here as it is over there. Being modern Orthodox in the UK is not really such a problem kosher food under the chief rabbi is relatively affordable

    ReplyDelete
  11. Your point?
    That people assimilate even though they received an Orthodox Jewish Education? I agree. Do most people assimilate after receiving an Orthodox Jewish Education? No

    Ps
    It's cute how you make things up to win an argument. The BeSh"t son a maskil? Wut???

    ReplyDelete

ANONYMOUS COMMENTS WILL NOT BE POSTED!
please use either your real name or a pseudonym.